I was eating lunch yesterday when I saw a news story about floods somewhere. Hundreds of people lost their homes. I felt a familiar pang of guilt.
Not guilt about the floods. I didn’t cause them. Guilt about my sandwich. About sitting in a dry room, complaining about nothing.
Why does being fine feel wrong when others aren’t?
Part of it is mathematical thinking. If there’s a fixed amount of good in the world, then me having some means less for everyone else. My comfort comes at their expense.
But that’s not how comfort works. Me being warm doesn’t make someone else cold. My safety doesn’t create their danger. The world isn’t a zero-sum game of wellbeing.
Another part is evolutionary. We’re wired to feel bad when our tribe suffers. It motivates helping behavior. The problem is that now our tribe is everyone. We get constant updates about every tragedy everywhere. Our Stone Age brains can’t handle the scale.
But I think the deepest part is about meaning. Suffering feels like it should mean something. If I’m fine while others hurt, then either their pain doesn’t matter or my peace is undeserved.
Neither feels right.
Maybe the guilt is useful anyway. It reminds us that comfort isn’t guaranteed. That other people’s pain is real even when we can’t feel it.
The trick is letting it motivate compassion without demanding we feel miserable whenever anyone else does.
Related reading: