Kant vs Utilitarianism: When Good Intentions Meet Good Outcomes
Kant and the utilitarians disagree about something fundamental: what makes an action right or wrong? Utilitarians say it’s all about consequences. An action is right if it produces the best overall outcome. Save ten lives by sacrificing one? Do it. The math works out. Kant says that’s backwards. What matters is your intention, your duty. Some actions are wrong regardless of their consequences. Don’t lie, even to save a life. Don’t use people as tools, even for a greater good....